I am working with a team to build out a social community portal in SharePoint 2013 for an Enterprise group. We have built multiple communities that all work as expected; however only one of the communities appears to not increment the reply count or reputation score. This same community is the only community that my team has customized. The scope of the customization has been changing the title, changing the site images, adding libraries, adding lists, creating pages and adding Apps/Web Parts on the pages. All work has been done strictly in the browser. What change to a community site template cause the reply count on the members page to stop incrementing? Is this a bug?
Please note that each community site is in it's own site collection with the root site collection being the community portal site template. As of right now, all site collections are using the same content database.
The most frustrating part is that this community site is failing with the incrementing count doesn't happen in the other communities when using the exact same permissions, configurations, and test cases.
Also, this is the RTM version, not beta.
Thanks!